Papa's Grill Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Papa's Grill, a sports bar and burger joint located in Columbus, IN. This casual dining spot offers a wide range of American classics, from juicy burgers to appetizing salads. With a variety of options for vegetarians and a full bar for those looking to unwind, Papa's Grill caters to all tastes.
Start your meal with the crowd-favorite Mozzarella Wedges or the crispy Papa's Onion Rings. For something heartier, try the Oriental Chicken Salad or the flavorful Grilled Cheese Dunkers with a side of House Cheesy Tomato Soup.
Whether you're looking for a family-friendly spot or a place to catch the game with friends, Papa's Grill has something for everyone. Don't forget to take advantage of their outdoor seating and free Wi-Fi. Come see what makes Papa's Grill a standout in the Columbus dining scene.
Appetizers
Mozzarella Wedges
Breaded wedges of mozzarella cheese with marinara sauce.
Papa's Onion Rings
Light crispy beer-battered onion rings with chipotle ranch.
Grilled Cheese Dunkers and a Bowl of Soup
House Cheesy Tomato Soup
Soups
Salads
Oriental Chicken Salad
A bed of fresh baby spinach topped with seasoned char-grilled chicken breast, diced tomatoes, cabbage, shredded cheddar-jack cheese, chow mein noodles, and toasted almonds. Served with sweet and spicy Asian ginger dressing.
Spinach Salad
A bed of spinach greens topped with sliced egg, red onions, crisp bacon, tomatoes, peas, and shredded cheddar-jack. Served with hot bacon or poppyseed dressing. Choose a dressing style: hot bacon, poppyseed dressing.
Boneless Wing Basket
Breaded chicken bites spun in one of papa's specialty sauces served with celery and your choice of bleu cheese or ranch dressing. Choose a dressing style: bleu cheese dressing, ranch dressing.
Popcorn Shrimp
1/2 lb. lightly battered tender shrimp served with papa's cocktail sauce.
Baskets
Sandwiches
Papa's Tenderloin Sandwich
Indiana's favorite pork tenderloin. Charbroiled or breaded and served with lettuce, tomatoes, pickle and red onions. Breaded tenderloin is cooked to medium-well and may appear to pink in color.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Charbroiled or breaded breast of chicken spun with papa's mild sauce and served on a bun with lettuce, tomatoes, pickle and red onions with choice of bleu cheese or ranch.